Lanny H Golf: Special Edition


As the entire world knows by now, Lanny H Golf was once again spotlighted in the Mailbag feature of famed sports journalist Gary Van Sickle (Sports Illustrated).

My query concerned the possibility of Jordan Spieth being named Sports Illustrated’s Sportsman of the Year.  I erroneously referred to the honor as SportsPERSON of the Year, thinking SportsMAN would be a no-no.  Alas, SI still calls the award Sportsman of the Year.  Good for them.  I jumped to my faulty conclusion based on, among other things, the fact that SI’s sister Publication, Time, changed their yearly award from Man of the Year to Person of the Year.

But enough about that.  Mr. Van Sickle, after chiding me for my political correctness, allowed this regarding Spieth:

Spieth is a leading candidate for Sportsman of the Year, as SI still calls it. But in the world of political correctness in the magazine biz, I’m going to say the U.S. women’s soccer team (maybe the whole team?) is the leader in the clubhouse, with Spieth and American Pharoah second by a nose.

It’s interesting that Van Sickle brings up political correctness.  That has been my biggest concern.  But, in my eyes, the choice has to be Jordan Spieth.  Let’s go through Van Sickle’s two mentions along with Serena Williams.

American Pharoah

Secretariat did not win the award.  Need I say more?

U.S. Women’s Soccer Team

The U.S. women winning the World Cup is just not that big of an accomplishment.  There have been seven Women’s World Cup competitions.  The U.S. has won three.  People seem to think that since it would be a miracle for the U.S. men’s team win the World Cup, it must be equally difficult for the women.  Nothing could be further from the truth.  The U.S. women’s soccer team has never finished worse than third.  (Third is the best the men’s team has managed in twenty World Cups — many for which they didn’t even qualify.  And that third came in 1930.)  If the women’s soccer team gets Sportswomen of the Year, the award has completely lost its way.

Serena Williams

She still has to be a consideration.  I don’t think her year was better than Jordan Spieth’s, but she had one helluva year, and she’s had one helluva career — without ever winning Sportswoman of the Year.  It seems obvious that SI cannot give the award to the women’s soccer team (for a second time) and snub Serena.

However, there are some major problems for Serena.  Stephie Graf won the Grand Slam in 1988 — then won three of four in 1989 — and yet SI did not reward her in either of those years.  Then there is Monica Seles, who won 7 of 9 Slam events before a psychopath stabbed her with a knife.  She never got Sportswoman of the Year during that great run, and who knows what she would have accomplished had she not been attacked.

Bottom line: Winning Grand Slam tennis events isn’t as difficult as winning major golf tournaments.  There was a six year period (1988-1993) when a woman won three or four Grand Slam events in five of those year. Three modern-era women have completed the Slam (1953, 1970, 1988).

Jordan Spieth

Jordan Spieth’s year is already, at a minimum, equal to Serena’s, and, should he win in Atlanta this week, would certainly surpass hers.  And we must not forget Jordan’s two majors and his run for the Grand Slam occurred when he was all of 21 years old.

Jordan also has this going for him:  Tiger Woods won the award as a youngster in 1996 for two big amateur wins and some weak PGA Tour fall series tournaments.  It is going to look very odd if Woods got the award for winning the U.S. Amateur and NCAA Championship and Jordan doesn’t for winning the U.S. Open and the Masters.

Cop Out

A very real possibility is a compromise, such as a “Crowns and Slams” winner, with American Pharoah, Serena Williams, and Jordan Spieth all honored as the Sportsman and Sportswoman and Sportshorse of the Year.  It still seems wrong to give American Pharoah the award when Secretariat didn’t win it, but, on the other hand, Serena and Jordan fell short of their ultimate goals.  American Pharoah did not.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Lanny H Golf: Special Edition

  1. Kris says:

    Maybe American Pharoah can’t win, but what about Victor Espinoza? Honestly, I’d be OK with that. If they want to honor a horse or an entire team they’re going to have to change the title of the award from “Sportsman of the Year” to “Sports Entity of the Year”.

    • lannyh says:

      Yeah, Steve Cauthen won in 1977 (I think it was), so, yeah, the jockey would have a legitimate claim. But the Secretariat jockey didn’t win, so we’re kind of back to that. I prefer Jordan to win, but a case can be made for the jockey.

  2. TigerFan says:

    Damn, after that beauty I’m rooting for anyone (anything?) other than Jordan for the shear entertainment value it’ll bring to hear you rant about how absurd it is that he didn’t win. I’ll get my popcorn ready!

  3. Ken says:

    It should be Tiger Woods. Because his kids are so beautiful and he brought them to Augusta and he’s just so nice and approachable now.

    • lannyh says:

      And he practiced chipping first thing, too, to show the world he was fearless about the rumored yips. How brave! And rockin’ those headphones. Hard to top all that, I suppose.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s